|

THE
PERSISTENCE OF BLUE
[Introduction]
On
a December morning in 1999, snowflakes swirled
around me as I entered a squat, near windowless
building on Tenth Avenue. The awning outside
read "Sony Music Studios." Inside, down
a dimly lit corridor lines with posters
of rock and rap artists, thick doors with
porthole windows led into fully furnished
studios, where large consoles with matrices
of red and white lights stood next to racks
full of the latest sound equipment. People
lost in concentration scurried past me.
The
few times I had visited the place before,
I had felt the same way: This hi-tech beehive,
a monument to Sony's global technological
superiority, seemed somehow transitory.
I felt that a careless flip of a switch
could plunge the entire place into darkness.
Maybe it was the signs of constant renovations
- plastic sheeting covering doorways-that
created the feeling of impermanence, or
perhaps it was the rotation of posters from
one visit to the next. It didn't surprise
me to learn that Sony Music had built their
recording center in the remains of the old
Twentieth Century-Fox Movietone repository.
Where dusty film canisters had once stored
a week-by-week chronicle of the world's
troubles and triumphs, four stories of state-of-the
art studios now operated: new technology
rising phoenix-like from the vestiges of
old.
Four
months earlier, for The New York Times,
I had written an appreciation of Miles Davis's
melancholy masterpiece Kind of Blue on the
fortieth anniversary of its release. Now
I had been granted a rare opportunity to
hear the complete master tapes of the two
sessions that produced the album. Sony Music-the
parent company of Columbia Records, which
released Kind of Blue and remained Miles's
record label for the majority of his career-did
not often send to their subterranean archives
in upstate New York and allow the reel-to-reel
tapes to be auditioned. When dealing with
priceless and irreplaceable forty-year old
recordings, even the wear on the tape is
a consideration. For a jazz fan like myself,
the occasion had the rarified, historic
air of, say, the unearthing of an Egyptian
tomb.
The
receptionist directed me to room 305. Equipment
dedicated to sound reproduction, including
a turntable in a stone base with a speed
lever reading "78 rpm," filled the room.
Sitting amid the machines, scattered tape
reels, vinyl records of varying formats,
and general clutter was an engineer trained
in audio formats new, old and ancient. In
this room, I was convinced, whatever means
of capturing audio information have ever
existed-wax cylinders to the latest computer-driven,
digital discs-all came back to life.
Delicately, the engineer placed a reel of
reddish-brown, half-inch ribbon onto a tape
machine, manufactured expressly to play
back archival three-track tapes. He paused,
asked if I was ready. (Ready? I had been
giddy with anticipation for weeks.) He hit
the "play" button.
The
tape threaded its way across the playback
heads and I heard the voices of Miles Davis
and his producer, Irving Townsend, the instantly
recognizable sound of Miles's trumpet, John
Coltrane's tenor, Cannonball Adderley's
alto and the other musicians. I listened
to their harmonized riffs start and stop
and grew acclimated to the rhythm of the
recording process. A few engineers who had
heard that the masters were being played
that day dropped by and quietly pulled up
chairs or stood in the corner to listen.
What could I hear or intuit that would reveal
the secret of that spring day when Davis
assembled his famed sextet (Coltrane, Adderley,
Bill Evans, Paul Chambers and Jimmy Cobb
with pianist Wynton Kelly taking over from
Evans on one number) in a converted church
in downtown Manhattan? I was flooded with
questions, hungry for details. How did this
band talk while creating music for the ages?
Was that Coltrane's voice or Adderley's?
How-if at all-did they prepare? What was
Miles like in the studio? Why did that take
end? I had learned that the three master
reels, the few rolls of black-and-white
film, and the less-than-distinct memories
of the drummer, a photographer, and a tape
operator who were in the East Thirtieth
Street studio back in 1959 were about all
the evidence there was of the making of
the album. The dearth of related material
only heightened the album's mystique and
intensified my desire to uncover anything
that might throw light on what seemed such
a shadowy, skeletal moment.
As
the first full take of "Freddie Freeloader"
began playing, I put down my pen and focused
on the music. By the time Coltrane began
soloing, I was transported to an austere
twilight world that requested silence and
contemplation. I was familiar with the album
from years of dedicated listening but the
music's seductive spell had not lessened
- it still held the power to quiet all around
it.
Still
acknowledged as the height of hip four decades
after it was recorded, Kind of Blue is the
premier album of its era, jazz or otherwise.
Its vapory piano-and -bass-phrased introduction
is universally recognized. Classical buffs
and rage rockers alike praise its subtlety,
simplicity and emotional depth. Copies of
the album are passed to friends and given
to lovers. The album has sold millions of
copies around the world, making it the best-selling
recording in Miles Davis's catalog and the
best-selling classic jazz album ever. Significantly,
a large number of those copies were purchased
in the past five years, and undoubtedly
not just by old-timers replacing worn vinyl:
Kind of Blue is even casting its spell on
a younger audience more accustomed to the
loud-and-fast esthetic of rock and rap.
The
album's appeal was certainly enhanced by
Miles's personal mystique. Cool, well-dressed,
endlessly inspired, and uncompromising in
art and life, Miles Davis was and still
is a hero to jazz fans, African Americans
and an international musical community.
"Miles Davis is my definition of cool,"
Bob Dylan has said. "I loved to see him
in the small clubs playing his solo, turn
his back on the crowd, put down his horn
and walk off the stage, let the band keep
playing, and then come back and play a few
notes at the end."
Since his death in 1991, Davis's legend
has only grown larger. But even before his
passing, Kind of Blue was the recording
that all agreed was his defining masterwork.
If someone has only one Miles album - or
even only one jazz recording - more often
than not, Kind of Blue is it. Even twenty-five
years ago, as jazz guitarist John Scofield
relates, the album had already become as
common as a cup of sugar:
I
remember at Berklee School [of Music in
Boston] in the early seventies, hanging
out at this bass player's apartment and
they didn't have Kind of Blue. So at two
in the morning he said he'd just go knock
on the neighbor's door and ask for their
copy, not knowing the people, just assuming
that they'd have it! And they did. It was
like Sergeant Pepper.
In
the church of jazz, Kind of Blue is one
of the holy relics. Critics revere it as
a stylistic milestone, one of a very few
in the long tradition of jazz performance,
on equal footing with seminal recordings
by Louis Armstrong's Hot Fives and Charlie
Parker's bebop quintets. Musicians acknowledge
its influence and have recorded hundreds
of versions of the music on the album. Record
producer, composer, and Davis confidant
Quincy Jones hails it as the one album (if
that were the limit) that would explain
jazz.
Yet,
Kind of Blue lives and prospers outside
the confines of the jazz community. No longer
the exclusive possession of a musical subculture,
the album is simply great music, one of
a very, very few musical recordings our
culture allows into the category marked
"masterpiece." Many of its admirers are
forced to reach back before the modern era
to find its measure. Drummer Elvin Jones
hears the same timeless sublimity and depth
of feeling "in some of the movements of
Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, or when I hear
Pablo Casals play unaccompanied cello."
"It's like listening to Tosca," says pianist/singer
Shirley Horn. "You know, you always cry,
or at least I do."
In
the fin-de-siecle frenzy, Kind of Blue proved
its evergreen appeal, becoming a fixture
in the first tier of countless "Best of
the Century" surveys and "Top 100" polls.
Hollywood film in the nineties employed
the album as an instant signifier of hip.
In the Line of Fire shows secret serviceman
Clint Eastwood, the cool loner at home,
listening to "All Blues." In Pleasantville,
the manager of a fifties diner finds his
creative inner-self to the tune of "So What."
In Runaway Bride, Julia Roberts' character
bestows an original vinyl copy of Kind of
Blue on Richard Gere.
As
I began the research for this book, Sony
Music was in the midst of producing high-quality
repackagings of Miles's recordings and of
jazz in general, a fortunate change from
the offhand reissue strategy of previous
decades. They graciously provided me complete
access to all information, photographs and
recordings in their archives, and facilitated
contact with former employees. I located
session and tape logs that disclosed the
identity of the recording staff who worked
on Kind of Blue, most of whom- like the
members of the sextet save for drummer Jimmy
Cobb - are no longer with us. My conversations
with Columbia engineers of that era painted
a picture of what it was like to work in
the 30th Street Studio, the former church
where the album was born. Sifting through
company files, I glimpsed the inner workings
of the marketing and promotion departments
which first brought Kind of Blue to market.
To
bring the reader as near as possible to
the actual creation of the album, I have
placed the transcription and discussion
of the record sessions at the heart of the
book. The unedited studio dialogue, false
starts and breakdowns-herein reproduced
for the first time-offer a rare glimpse
of the inner workings of those two days
in the studio. The transcribed chatter alone,
revealing Cannonball Adderly's irrepressible
sense of humor and Miles's constant ribbing
of his producer, will delight those who
love the music that occasioned it.
I stumbled on a number of surprises in my
research. There were Bill Evans's original
liner notes, neatly handwritten and hardly
edited at all. Engineer Fred Plaut's photographs,
never published before now, showing the
sheet music for the album's modal infrastructure.
Proof that the famously dark and intense
cover shot of Miles was taken during a live
performance at the Apollo Theater. Never-before-published
radio conversations with Adderley and Evans
in which they spoke of Miles and the album
in detail, conveying a personal dimension
that published interviews never could.
Beyond
the new information my research yielded
about Kind of Blue, I was equally drawn
by the more mystical aspects of the album.
The legend of its pure, one-take creation.
The alchemic blending of classical and folk
music influences. The interplay of Miles's
less-is-more philosophy with the styles
of the equally spare Bill Evans and his
other, more voluble sidemen. The drama of
Davis's own presence, the artist driven
by an endless search for new styles who
created a masterwork, then left it behind
for his next endeavor. I was challenged
to examine what is true in the mythology
of the recording. Was the album really impromptu
and unplanned? Did Miles really compose
all the music? Did it change the jazz terrain
forever, and if so, how?
To
do the album justice, I needed to transport
myself back to the place and time that brought
it forth. I spoke with as many musicians,
producers, and critics as possible - those
who were involved in making the album, were
influenced by the music, or who analyzed
its effects. Eventually I conducted more
than fifty interviews for this book, including
talks with veteran jazzmen who knew or worked
with Miles, newer arrivals who grew up with
his music, producers, music industry executives,
deejays, writers, and witnesses of the jazz
scene of the 1950s. Priority was given to
the people still alive who were present
at the two Kind of Blue recording sessions:
drummer Jimmy Cobb, photographer Don Hunstein,
and tape operator Bob Waller.
I found that though a few musicians and
producers were reluctant to speak, burned
out on the subject of Miles or simply burned
by the trumpeter in uncomplimentary portrayals
in interviews or in his autobiography, many
were eager to share their memories and insights.
I gave special attention to those who worked
with Miles in and around 1959, or soon after:
Jimmy Heath, Dave Brubeck, George Russell,
John Lewis, Joe Zawinul and Herbie Hancock;
producers George Avakian and Teo Macero;
and engineer Frank Laico.
Some
saw Kind of Blue as the sound of 1950s New
York; some as a high point in Miles's career
trajectory; others as one more successful
product of a record label at the height
of its dominance. As the anecdotes coalesced,
the structure for the book that suggested
itself was a reverse telescopic path - beginning
with Miles's arrival in New York, then following
his career course before closing in take-by-take
on the album's two recording sessions. From
there, the book moves outward again to trace
the album's influence. Sidebars add further
context: Columbia Records' rise to prominence
and its role in the success of Kind of Blue;
the unique acoustical properties that made
music recorded at the 30th Street Studio
distinctive; the eponymous Freddie Freeloader.
When I spoke of writing this celebration
of Kind of Blue, whether to music professionals
or to fans, reaction was uniformly positive:
"You know, that's a good idea"; "Let's hear
more about that album"; "It's about time."
Then after a pause, with little or no solicitation,
a testimonial would follow.
Quincy
Jones: "That will always be my music, man.
I play Kind of Blue every day - it's my
orange juice. It still sounds like it was
made yesterday."
Chick
Corea: "It's one thing to just play a tune,
or play a program of music, but it's another
thing to practically create a new language
of music, which is what Kind of Blue did."
George
Russell: "Kind of Blue is just one of those
amazing albums that emerged from that period
of time. Miles's solo on 'So What' is one
of the most beautiful solos ever."
With the clarity of memory usually reserved
for national disasters, personal traumas,
or first romantic encounters, many I interviewed
recalled their first hearing of Kind of
Blue. Some encountered the music when it
first appeared in 1959: on a late-night
radio station in Cleveland; in a Wisconsin
furniture store selling records; live in
a New York nightclub or at an outdoor festival
in Toronto; on a jukebox in a Harlem watering
hole. Others came across it in the sixties:
the mono LPs a friendly sales clerk with
a flowered tie was selling off at a dollar
a disc; playing at a late-night party down
in Greenwich Village. One acquaintance admitted
hearing Kind of Blue in a college class
on Zen.
Kind of Blue's aphrodisiac properties were
mentioned frequently in reminiscences of
listeners male and female, young and not-so-young.
Jazz veteran Ben Sidran recalls that "clearly
it was just a great seduction record. I
can close my eyes and remember situations
with long forgotten girls." Anthony Kiedis
of the Red Hot Chili Peppers, when asked
for his favorite make-out music, answered
"For slow action, I put on Kind of Blue."
Because of "the trance-like atmosphere that
it created, it's like sexual wallpaper.
It was sort of the Barry White of its time,"
remembers Steely Dan's Donald Fagen. Essayist/playwright
Pearl Cleage was turned on to the album
in the late seventies: "I will confess that
I spent many memorable evenings sending
messages of great personal passion through
the intricate improvisations of Kind of
Blue when blue was the furthest thing from
my mind..."
My
own discovery of the music came in the mid-seventies,
when a high-school buddy yanked a dogeared
album out of my father's record collection
and explained: "This is a classic." Between
the scratches and pops (Dad must play this
one a lot, I recall thinking) a stark, moody
world unveiled itself. Though the sound
was far simpler and sadder than any of the
peppy, big band music I then thought of
as jazz, it was somehow immediately familiar.
If
you are already a fan of the album, perhaps
a "first time" story of your own comes to
mind. Or ask the friend who turned you onto
Kind of Blue. Bring that memory with you
to the world we're about to enter. Use this
book as a primer, a listening guide, a way
to understand that there is even more to
these forty minutes of great jazz performance
than meets the ear. Allow this book to show
you that occasionally that which is the
least outspoken has the most to say.
Session
photograph © Don Hunstein |